Background
Pakistan's education policy framework appears to be riddled with critical flaws that undermine the nation's progress in providing quality education to its citizens. Unfortunately, Pakistan has one of the world's largest ratio of the out of school children. At present, Pakistan has 58% to 59% literacy ratio which indicates that around 100 million people of Pakistan are illiterate.
Over the past 76 years, total six educational policies have been devised in Pakistan including some amendments but none of them has achieved any fruitful results. These shortcomings are an open indicative of a systemic issue that requires immediate attention and reforms.
Keeping in view the above mentioned facts and figures, this critical review will dissect the key themes that highlight the inadequacies within Pakistan's education policy.
1. Policy Development in Ivory Towers:
One glaring issue is the creation of educational policies within the confines of drawing rooms and distant government offices. This approach seems to detach policy formulation from the ground realities, leading to a lack of understanding of the actual needs and challenges faced by schools and students.
Similarly, just devising an educational policy every after 10 to 12 years is not a solution. Rather its relevance with the existing ground realities including proper implementation framework is indeed the need of the hour.
2. Exclusion of Key Stakeholders:
The absence of teachers, parents, and local communities in the policymaking process is a significant oversight. These stakeholders possess invaluable insights into the needs and challenges of the education system. Ignoring their voices can result in policies that are out of touch with the grassroots.
While analysing all the six previous educational policies of Pakistan, it is evident that key stakeholders have never been given any importance while making policies. Theoretical frameworks and assumptions are not enough while framing an educational policy. There is always a dire need for considering ground realities and taking proper consultation from all the stakeholders before developing any educational policy.
3. Budget Mismanagement:
The misallocation of meager budgets allocated to education is another grave concern. Adequate financial resources are vital for improving infrastructure, teacher training, and access to quality materials. Mismanagement can hinder progress and exacerbate existing disparities.
Similarly, there is a dire need that from top to bottom level only educational experts should be hired at management level. In this regard, local educational experts must be given priority. In the prosperity and viable development of any country, education plays a very significant role. Therefore, enough budget should be allocated as per the needs and requirements of the 21st century teaching and learning process.
4. Inadequate Facilities:
A glaring gap exists in terms of educational facilities, including transportation, furniture, equipment, and laboratories. Without proper infrastructure, students' learning experiences are compromised, perpetuating an inequitable system.
Similarly, instead of building too much schools in every nook and corner of the country is certainly not the solution. Instead a cluster and main campus schools should be constructed including providing them all the basic facilities such as transportation, technology access, and digital management.
5. Rural-Urban Education Divide:
Pakistan struggles with a stark urban-rural education divide. While there is a proliferation of primary and secondary schools, the lack of facilities and quality education in rural areas exacerbates this divide, perpetuating inequality.
On the other hand, Pakistan is an agricultural country where 45% of its total population directly and indirectly depends on agriculture. Therefore, agriculture sector should be the top priority particularly at rural level. In this regard, technical and vocational education setup be established throughout the countryside areas of Pakistan.
6. Lack of Research and Assessment:
The absence of comprehensive research, evaluation, assessment, and analysis of educational policies and their impact is concerning. Without data-driven insights, policymakers are left in the dark about what works and what doesn't.
Therefore, at local level, research process should be initiated including getting key insights. Similarly, it should be realized that research is effective when it is done and implemented in the same area or region. On the other hand, research without assessment and evaluation will not produce any fruitful results as theory and practical work go hand in hand.
7. Overreliance on Policy Papers:
Relying solely on policy documents without considering ground realities can lead to the implementation of impractical or ineffective solutions. This lack of alignment between policy and practice is detrimental to the education system.
Developing a policy document without considering the ground realities is like a car without an engine. Therefore, merely relying on policy papers including hiring consultants will not bring any viable change in education sector until and unless ground realities are not given proper weightage.
8. Implementation Challenges:
A key issue is the failure to implement policies effectively. Policies often remain on paper and fail to address the real issues faced by schools and students on the ground. This lack of practicality hampers progress.
Framing a policy is just a first step towards a journey. Therefore, a journey cannot be achieved without framing implementation, analysis, evaluation, synthesis, and effective management plan.
9. Lack of Educational Support:
There is a noticeable absence of educational seminars, workshops, and sessions aimed at improving literacy in rural areas. Such initiatives are crucial for equipping teachers with the necessary skills to enhance the quality of education.
Similarly, government should hold information based sessions and seminars so that importance of education can be propagated among masses.
On the other hand, masses should also be given an opportunity to have their say and express their various issues including poverty and inaccessible educational opportunities which are causing illiteracy in the rural areas.
10. Inclusive Education Approach:
The absence of an inclusive education approach further hinders efforts to improve literacy in rural areas. Addressing poverty and dropout issues should be integral to the education policy framework, as these factors are intertwined with educational outcomes.
Particularly, girls' education in the rural areas due to multiple issues create severe problems including huge dropouts. Pakistan's 50% population is based on females, however they are constantly being ignored particularly in countryside areas.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Pakistan's education policy framework is marred by a multitude of critical flaws, ranging from the disconnected nature of policy development to the lack of adequate resources and inclusive approaches.
To bridge the education gap and foster equitable access to quality education, urgent reforms are needed to address these systemic issues and bring about positive change in Pakistan's education system.
Without addressing all the above mentioned flaws, Pakistan cannot achieve the desired results as far as quality education is concerned.
Comments