Skip to main content

Critical Analysis of the Western Educational Philosophy

 Western Educational Philosophy 

Overview

Western educational philosophy has deep roots linked with famous Greek philosophers including Plato, Aristotle, and Socrates. However, it started emerging during the Renaissance period which started after the Medieval age. Similarly, after the French revolution, Western educational philosophy started getting recognition at the international level. 

Additionally, since the beginning of the 19th century, the West emerged as a dominant region in the field of science, research, discoveries, and education in particular.  Since then till today, Western educational philosophy is leading the world in major fields of science, technology, communication, and quality education. 

Western Educational Philosophy

Unlike the Islamic philosophy of education and Eastern educational philosophy, Western educational philosophy promotes individualism and inventiveness towards learners. Students who have the freedom to express their creativity do not fear being different or making errors since Western education views mistakes as valuable learning opportunities.

Additionally, Western educational philosophy heavily relies on and revolves around the following given seven philosophies of education that mainly focus on teachers and students. These seven Western philosophies in education are defined as under.

  •  Behaviorism
  • Constructivism 
  •  Essentialism
  •  Existentialism
  •  Humanism
  •  Perennialism
  •  Progressivism

Behaviorism Theory in Education

Behaviorism came about in the early 1900s as a reaction to depth psychology and other traditional forms of psychology, which often had trouble making predictions that could be tested experimentally but were derived from earlier research from the late 1800s. Behaviorism also came about as a reaction to these traditional forms of psychology. 

Similarly, the particular idea that all behaviors are learned through interaction with the environment is at the center of behaviorism theory in education. According to this learning theory, innate or inherited factors have very little effect on behavior, and behaviors are learned from the environment.

Rewarding students or a class with a party or special treat at the end of the week for good behavior throughout the week is an example of behaviorism. When it comes to punishments, the same idea is used. If a student behaves badly, the teacher has the authority to revoke certain privileges.

Constructivism Theory in Education

Constructivism is a school of thought that holds the view that students do not passively acquire knowledge and understanding through a direct transmission of knowledge; rather, they construct new understandings and knowledge through social discourse and experience, integrating new information with what they already know (previous knowledge). 

This includes knowledge acquired prior to entering school for children. It is connected to a number of different philosophical positions, particularly epistemology, ontology, ethics, and politics. The theory also has a connection to the cognitive development theory of Swiss developmental psychologist Jean Piaget.

Essentialism Theory in Education

One of the most influential proponents of essentialism was William Bagley. Bagley was of the opinion that education was not meant to alter society but rather to preserve it. The adherents of educational essentialism hold the belief that children should thoroughly learn the traditional fundamental subjects. Taking a back-to-basics approach, this philosophical school of thought aims to teach students the "essentials" of academic knowledge. 

Similarly, Essentialism ensures that students acquire the accumulated wisdom of our civilization through traditional academic disciplines. Reading, writing, literature, foreign languages, history, mathematics, science, art, and music are all examples of such fields. In addition, this conventional strategy aims to train the mind, encourage reasoning, and guarantee a common culture.

Existentialism Theory in Education

The problem of human existence is the focus of existentialist philosophy, which focuses on the subjective experience of thinking, feeling, and acting. The meaning, purpose, and value of human existence are frequently examined by existentialist thinkers. "Existentialism" is a feeling of dread, disorientation, confusion, or anxiety in the face of an apparently meaningless or absurd world, according to an existentialist perspective. 

Several European philosophers of the 19th and 20th centuries are associated with existentialism because they all placed an emphasis on the human subject, despite frequently profound differences in thought.

Humanism Theory in Education

Humanism is a philosophical perspective that places an emphasis on the potential and agency of humans as individuals as well as in society. Human beings are regarded as the foundation for serious moral and philosophical investigation. Humanistic values were bolstered by technological and scientific advancements during the Enlightenment, giving people the confidence to explore the world. Humanism Philosophy revolves around the holistic development of a learner. 

Organizations solely dedicated to humanism flourished in Europe and the United States at the beginning of the 20th century and have since spread worldwide. The term generally refers to a focus on human well-being and advocates for human progress, freedom, and autonomy in the present day. It emphasizes a concern for humans in relation to the world, espouses the equality and inherent dignity of all humans, and views humanity as responsible for the advancement and development of individuals.

Perennialism Theory in Education

The belief that all religious traditions around the world share a single metaphysical truth or origin, from which all esoteric and exoteric knowledge and doctrine have developed, is known as the philosophy of perennials. Perennials hold the belief that centuries-old ideas ought to be the primary focus of education. They think that the concepts are just as relevant and important now as they were when they were written.

They suggest that understudies gain from perusing and examining crafted by history's best scholars and journalists. Every student in a classroom taught by a seasoned teacher would be treated equally. Students are exposed to the material whether or not they are interested in it. This is because rather than teaching them what they like, the material is taught to benefit them.

Progressivism Theory in Education

A school of thought known as progressivism holds that human societies can improve over time through political action. Progressivism is a political movement that asserts that social reform based on advancements in science, technology, economic development, and social organization will improve the human condition. 

People who adhere to this way of thinking believe that progressivism can be applied to all societies and work to spread this idea everywhere. During the Age of Enlightenment, progressivism emerged out of the belief that the application of new empirical knowledge to society's governance was enhancing civility in Europe.

You may Also Read:


Comments

Basit110 said…
Great insights raja

Most Read Blogs

Single National Curriculum (SNC): Its Pros & Cons

Single National Curriculum 2020  Background Pakistan is a multi-lingual, multi-cultural, and multi-ethnic country where around 74 different languages are spoken. Out of these 74 different languages, 66 languages are indigenous while the remaining 8 are non-indigenous. Urdu is the national language while English is the official language of Pakistan.  Similarly, Pakistan is the thick and second-largest Muslim-populated country in the world. Approximately 96.5% (≈210 million) people are Muslims, out of which around 85-90% are Sunni and the remaining are the Shia sect Muslims.  These two major sects are further subdivided into different groups on the basis of their particular schools of the so-called Islam ic law. On the other hand Pakistani nation is divided on the basis of political parties, ethnicity, sectarianism, culture, customs, traditions, rituals, socio-economics, and educational differences.  The current government has therefore developed and devised Single N...

School, Community, and Teacher (B.Ed Honours Course)

School, Community, & Teacher  (SCT) in the Context of Teacher Education (B.Ed Honours Course) Background The triad of school, community, and teacher (SCT) forms a critical intersection within the educational landscape, creating an integrated ecosystem essential for fostering a healthy and sustainable teaching and learning environment . In the realm of teacher education, the terms school, teacher, and community carry multifaceted meanings that vary depending on contextual factors. To fully comprehend the overarching goals and objectives of teacher education, it is imperative to explore the synergies and intersections inherent in this SCT framework. In this discussion, we will examine each component of the SCT triad in detail, while also considering related concepts that enrich our understanding of this complex interplay. By unpacking these terms, we aim to illuminate their significance and the ways in which they collectively contribute to a robust educational experience. The sch...

Definition and Scope of Statistics (Quantitative Reasoning Course)

Quantitative Reasoning Course for BS Honours Level Students  Definition and Scope of Statistics Statistics is the branch of mathematics that deals with the collection, analysis, interpretation, presentation, and organisation of data. It provides tools and methods to make sense of numerical information, identify patterns, draw inferences, and make informed decisions under uncertainty. The scope of statistics is broad and interdisciplinary: Descriptive Statistics : Summarises and describes the features of a dataset, such as calculating means, medians, or creating charts to visualise data. Inferential Statistics : Uses sample data to make generalisations or predictions about a larger population, often involving hypothesis testing, confidence intervals, and regression analysis. Applied Fields : Extends to economics (e.g., forecasting trends), biology (e.g., clinical trials), social sciences (e.g., surveys), engineering (e.g., quality control), and data science (e.g., machine learning m...

Dilema of Democracy & Political Leadership Crisis in Pakistan

Dilemma of Democracy & Political Leadership Crisis in Pakistan Overview Since mid 20th century,  Democracy is being considered the most accomplished process and a form of government where only people’s representatives have the right and authority to run the affairs of the state including forming certain constitutional rules and regulations.  Through democracy, people choose their representatives following a well-defined system of voting. The elected representatives then govern the affairs of the state on behalf of their people for a certain period of time (usually 4 to 5 years).  These representatives actually ensure the authority and rule of law for their people in the larger interests of any nation, state, or country. On the other hand, they are also held accountable and responsible for their actions and exercising of the powers within certain limitations as defined in the constitution or legislated through parliament.  Although Pakistan is a pure democratic...

Quantitative Reasoning: Statistics and its Relevance in the Context of BS English/Education Course

Introduction to Quantitative Reasoning Course   Quantitative Reasoning (QR) is an ability and an academic skill to use mathematical concepts and procedures. QR often involves interpretation of empirical and numerical data, identification of patterns, flow charts, geometrical shapes, and diagrams for identifying real life problems including offering viable solutions.  QR requires logical reasoning and critical thinking to analyse the real life issues and making informed decisions. Learners often require to have some basic knowledge about statistics numeracy, quantitative values, ratio as well as descriptive and inferential statistical analyses. Hence, in order to have reasonable grasp on QR, learners require to have the basic knowledge about Statistics. In simple words, Statistics plays a very pivotal role in understanding Quantitative Reasoning. What is Statistics? Statistics is one of the Branches of Applied Mathematics or  science of collecting, organising, analysing,...

Quantitative Reasoning Statistical Basics

Measures of Central Tendency Measures of central tendency are the specific statistical values which describe the typical values or central position of a dataset. The three most common single statistical values include Mean, Median and Mode.  Arithmetic Mean : Average of all values (sum divided by count). Geometric Mean : nth root of the product of values (used for growth rates). Harmonic Mean : The Reciprocal of the average of reciprocals (used for rates like speed). Median : Middle value when data is ordered. Quartiles : Values dividing data into four equal parts (Q1=25th, Q2=50th=median, Q3=75th percentile). Mode : Most frequent value. Measures of Dispersion Range : Difference between maximum and minimum values. Quartile Deviation : Half the interquartile range (Q3 - Q1)/2. Mean Deviation : Average absolute deviation from the mean. Variance : Average squared deviation from the mean. Standard Deviation : Square root of variance (spread in original units). Coefficient of Varia...

AFGHANISTAN CRISES: WHERE DOES PAKISTAN STAND?

Afghanistan Crises and Pakistan  Background According to history, Afghanistan has remained a war zone and a plan to invade central and south Asia for a long time. All of the invaders' troops entered South Asia through Afghanistan, from the Aryans to the Mughals. Afghanistan was the target of two major invasions in recent history. The former Soviet Union (USSR) launched its first invasion in December 1979, which lasted until 1989 and culminated in the dissolution of the Soviet Union into a number of distinct states. However, a significant portion of the formal USSR's territory, now known as the Russian Federation, is still there. As a result of the so-called September 11, 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center in New York, the United States of America (USA) and its NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) allies, including Great Britain, launched the second invasion in 2001. Al-Qaeda's leader, Usama Bin Ladin, was allegedly blamed for the 9/11 attacks and claims that Al-Qa...

SWOT Analysis within the Context of Education

 SWOT Analysis in Education for Curriculum Development, Classroom Management, and Planning Introduction   It was the Stanford Research Institute (SRI) which coined the term SWOT Analysis during the 1960s. Initially, the term was used for business management consultancy but later on, researchers and professionals started using it in different fields mainly for planning purposes. SWOT  analysis is a strategic planning tool or a framework which is used to identify and evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats related to an organization or a specific project including setting its standing operating procedures (SOPs).  It is widely used in business studies, politics, strategic military planning, think tanks, policy-making, international relations, socio-economic as well as socio-political dimensions, and education etc. Similarly, in the context of education, SWOT analysis provides a very comprehensive framework for assessing various aspects of educat...

Social Media Literacy and Educational Approaches in the 21st Century Teaching & Learning Context: B.Ed Honours Course Content

Social Media Literacy & Modes of Education in 21st Century (B.Ed Honours) Course Content Introduction The term social media refers to the digital interaction among different social groups. One of the most integral aspects of human life in the 21st century is social media, and it has significantly transformed how individuals communicate, interact, and gain information. Social media has opened the door to new opportunities for learning and information sharing including diverse challenges for teachers and learners in the process of teaching and learning.  In less advanced countries like Pakistan, teachers are still reluctant to use social media platforms while teaching because they lack certain skills to use different social media platforms effectively. As a result of it, such teachers rely on outdated traditional methods of teaching. On the other hand, many students believe that the purpose of social media use is just for entertainment and informal interaction with digital friend...

BOOKS ARE THE BEST OF ALL THE FRIENDS!

Books are the Best of all the Friends  Overview: Francis Bacon rightly said that “some books are tasted, others to be swallowed, and some few to be chewed and digested”. In his quote, Bacon emphasized that there are very few books only to be read out as wholly because they draw our attention with diligence and develop curiosity as we go on reading them further and further. Actually, books are the food for our brains and thoughts. They provide us knowledge, and deep information and develop creativity along with critical thinking skills.  Books lead us towards a world of fantasy and imagination and pose various logical and rational questions and intend to seek our reflection. According to Charles W. Eliot, “books are the quietest and most constant of friends; they are the most accessible and wisest of counselors, and the most patient of teachers”. Books are best friends and they are always ready to talk to us and share their information and experiences with us. Books are mi...