For B.Ed Hons level students, understanding curriculum design is not just a theoretical exercise; it is the foundation of becoming a "Teacher-Researcher" who can adapt national standards to local realities.
Introduction and Background
In the field of education, "Linear Models" are structured, step-by-step frameworks where one stage must be completed before moving to the next. These models are often called Rational Models because they follow a logical sequence.
For teachers in Pakistan, specifically within the Sindh Education and Literacy Department (SELD) framework, these models offer two different philosophies. One relies on centralised authority (Tyler), while the other empowers the classroom teacher (Taba). Understanding these models is crucial for implementing the National Curriculum of Pakistan (NCP) at the provincial and district levels.
1. Tyler’s Rationale: The Administrative Blueprint
Developed by Ralph Tyler, this is a deductive model. It moves from the general (policy) to the specific (classroom).
The Four Pillars
Determining Objectives: What do we want students to learn? In Sindh, this is often seen in the SLOs (Student Learning Outcomes) provided by the Sindh Textbook Board.
Identifying Learning Experiences: What activities will help? (e.g., Reading about the Indus River).
Organising Experiences: Logic and sequence. (e.g., Teaching "Liquid Properties" before "Irrigation Systems").
Evaluation: Testing to see if the SLOs were achieved through standardised board exams.
Real-Life Example: The implementation of a new province-wide English textbook where every school in Karachi, Hyderabad, Mirpur Khas, Nawabshah, Sukkur, and Larkana division follows the same objectives set by a central committee.
2. Taba’s Grassroots Model: The Teacher’s Innovation
Hilda Taba argued that the "top-down" approach ignores the diversity of learners. She proposed an inductive model, arguing that teachers, who know the students best, should begin the design process.
Why it matters for Sindh: A student in a coastal village in Thatta has different daily experiences than a student in a high-rise in Karachi. Taba’s model allows the teacher to bridge that gap.
3. Practical Application: A Localised Science Unit
Let’s apply Taba’s 7 steps to create a Science unit for a Grade 6 class in rural Sindh, focusing on a local environmental issue.
Topic: The Ecosystem of the Manchar Lake and Water Quality
Step 1: Diagnosis of Needs
The teacher notices that students are aware of the declining fish population in Manchar Lake and the rising salinity of the water, but they don't understand the chemical "why" behind it.
Step 2: Formulation of Objectives
Students will define "Salinity" and "Pollution."
Students will analyse how agricultural runoff affects local aquatic life.
Step 3: Selection of Content
The concept of PH levels.
The impact of the Right Bank Outfall Drain (RBOD) on local water.
The life cycle of indigenous fish like Palla.
Step 4: Organisation of Content
Start with the familiar (the local lake), move to the scientific cause (drainage systems and salt), and end with the global context (environmental protection).
Step 5: Selection of Learning Experiences
Instead of just a textbook, the teacher organises a "Water Sampling" activity where students bring water from different local sources (well, hand-pump, lake, tap).
Step 6: Organisation of Learning Activities
Observation: Looking at water under a microscope.
Experiment: Testing water with litmus paper.
Interview: Talking to local fishermen about fish catches 10 years ago vs. today.
Step 7: Evaluation
Students create a "Community Awareness Poster" in Sindhi or Urdu to explain to their families how to filter water or why certain pollutants are dangerous.
Comparison Summary for B.Ed Students
| Feature | Tyler’s Rationale | Taba’s Grassroots |
| Philosophy | Management-centred | Teacher-centred |
| Starting Point | National/Provincial Goals | Student/Community Needs |
| Flow | Objectives → Evaluation | Diagnosis→ Objectives |
| Localisation | Harder to adapt quickly | Designed specifically for local use |
Why this matters for your Career:
As a B.Ed graduate in Sindh, you will likely work with a fixed syllabus (Tyler’s influence). However, to be an effective teacher, you must use Taba’s steps to make that syllabus relevant to your specific students' lives, whether they are in an urban centre or a desert village in Tharparkar.
Comments