Teacher Education in Sindh, Pakistan and Global Context: A Detailed Comparative Analysis
🇵🇰 I. Teacher Education in Sindh, Pakistan: Structure and Systemic Challenges
Teacher education in Sindh is undergoing a transition from traditional, low-quality certification models to modern, standards-based professional degrees, regulated by the Sindh Teacher Education Development Authority (STEDA). However, there are different challenges, including framing proper policies and their effective implementation. In this regard, important insights are mentioned below.
A. Regulatory Framework and Reforms (STEDA)
The Role of STEDA: Established under the STEDA Act, 2012, its primary mandate is to oversight, regulate, and maintain pedagogical standards in the sector. Key functions include:
Accreditation and Standardisation: Setting standards for Teacher Education Institutes (TEIs) and phasing out outdated programs (like PTC/CT) in favour of modern ones, such as the Associate Degree in Education (ADE) and the four-year B.Ed. Honours (B.Ed. Hons.).
Professionalisation: Developing and implementing a Teaching Licence Policy to ensure entry into the profession is based on assessed competence, aligning the sector with the National Professional Standards for Teachers (NPST) set by the National Accreditation Council for Teacher Education.
B. Systemic Challenges and Impediments
The effective implementation of reforms is severely hampered by deep-seated governance issues, incompetent bureaucrats, corrupt practices, and infrastructural issues. In this regard, some of the most common aspects are discussed below.
Governance Failures:
Political Interference: This is the most destructive challenge. Nepotism, the induction of incompetent professionals, and political influence in the recruitment, transfer, and posting of teachers override merit, often leading to underqualified individuals holding key teaching and administrative positions.
Weak Accountability: Ineffective monitoring allows widespread teacher absenteeism and the persistence of "ghost schools" (non-functional schools), lowering the credibility and overall performance of the public sector. Various international donor agencies, including UNICEF, USAID, World Bank, ADB and UK Aid Direct, have also failed to ensure proper accountability for funds allocation and utilisation.
Copy Culture: The high incidence of cheating in SSC/HSC/B. Ed (college-side) level examinations (facilitated by corrupt practices) devalue degrees and undermine the intellectual integrity required of teacher graduates.
Infrastructural and Resource Deficiencies:
Many public schools lack basic necessities (clean water, functional washrooms, proper seating, and electricity).
There is a critical absence of modern resources like functioning science labs, adequate libraries, and reliable Information and Communication Technology (ICT) infrastructure, preventing the adoption of active and technology-integrated pedagogy.
Quality and Relevance:
Training programs are often criticised as being too theoretical and knowledge-based rather than application-based, failing to equip teachers with the critical, pedagogical, social, and ethical skills required for modern classrooms.
🌍 II. Global Teacher Education: Best Practices and Models
Globally, the focus is on elevating teaching to a research-informed, reflective, and highly selective profession capable of fostering 21st-century skills.
A. The Finnish Model: A Benchmark of Quality
Finland represents the pinnacle of teacher education, prioritising quality, autonomy, and research:
Academic Rigour: All basic and secondary teachers must hold a Master's degree in Education or their subject area with substantial pedagogical studies.
High Selectivity: Teaching programs are highly competitive, accepting only the top academic performers, ensuring a high-quality talent pool.
Research-Based Practice: Teachers are trained as autonomous, reflective practitioners who use educational research and data to continuously evaluate and improve their pedagogical decisions.
Professional Autonomy: Teachers are afforded high levels of trust and autonomy in curriculum design and assessment, fostering innovation and professional responsibility.
B. Competency-Based Teacher Education (CBTE)
CBTE is a global trend that focuses on demonstrable skills and performance rather than just time spent in classes:
Focus on Measurable Competencies: The system is built on explicit, measurable standards covering professional skills (e.g., classroom management), subject knowledge, and ethical dispositions.
Performance-Based Assessment: Trainees advance by demonstrating mastery through performance tasks, portfolios, practicums, and micro-teaching, rather than just passing traditional exams.
Integration of Theory and Practice: Learning is highly practical, directly linking theoretical studies to real-world classroom application and continuous, specific feedback.
🌐 III. Comparative Analysis: The Gap Between Sindh and Global Norms
The following comparison (Table 1) reveals a significant chasm in focus, quality assurance, and professional status.
Table 1: Indicating Comparative Analysis
| Feature | Sindh, Pakistan (Challenges) | Global Norms (Best Practices) |
| Entry Bar and Status | Low status; entry often compromised by political interference; reliance on low-quality, marketised programs. | High status; academically selective (e.g., Master's degree required in Finland); stringent licensing and professional standards. |
| Pedagogical Approach | Largely teacher-centred; reliance on memorisation and passive knowledge transfer; limited use of modern technology. | Learner-centred; focus on critical thinking, active learning, differentiation, and seamless technology integration. |
| Focus of Training | Narrow focus on technical knowledge and compliance; often lacks philosophical/ethical depth. | Holistic development; training in research, ethics, social responsibility, and specialised pedagogical techniques (CBTE). |
| Quality Assurance | Weak enforcement of standards (STEDA); high levels of corruption undermine merit and accountability. | Strong, independent professional bodies enforce rigorous, evidence-based accreditation and licensing (e.g., in North America and Europe). |
| Driver of Reform | Often, policy-driven (donor-supported) attempts to counter systemic failures and meet quantitative targets. | Continuous, research-driven evolution aimed at meeting the complex demands of the 21st-century global economy. |
For teacher education in Sindh to truly professionalise and align with global standards, the focus must shift from structural reform (which is underway) to quality implementation, rigorous enforcement of meritocracy, and sustained investment in both teacher resources and school infrastructure.
In conclusion, the structural and organisational system already exists, the only thing needed to make it properly functional by prioritise the right person for the right place. Additionally, strict checks and balances, including ensuring accountability, meritocracy, transparency, auditing, and need-based utilisation of the budget, can definitely bring positive change in it.
✍️ By: Raja Bahar Khan Soomro
Comments